General comment on draft-ietf-problem-statement-00.txt

[RJ Atkinson]

On Friday, Feb 28, 2003, at 10:22 America/Montreal, Keith Moore wrote:
> I'll respond in detail to the draft later.  But my impression is that
> this draft is just a start - it contains some serious 
> mis-characterizations
> and omissions that aren't likely to be fixed in a single revision.  
> I'm all
> for finishing this WG quickly, but I do think we need to be sure that 
> we
> have a good understanding of the problems before we try to work on 
> solutions.
>
> Keith

Keith,

	Sorry, but that is just NOT helpful.

	If you have issues, please take the time to put them on the table
and please try to do so within a reasonable timeframe.  If you don't
put specific concerns on the table, the editor of the draft has zero 
chance
of responding to them and the WG as a whole has zero chance to review
and comment on those concerns.

	And responding to this note to the list with anything other than 
specific
issues also would not be helpful.

Ran