[RTW] [dispatch] Does RTC-WEB need to pick a signaling protocol?

[Henry Sinnreich]

+1

> The SIP implementation can live
> in the JavaScript, up in the web server, in a separate gateway, or any
> combination thereof.

Or even in a browser add-in, perish the thought :-)

The main point here is to avoid the Chronos effect from SIP and XMPP
(has to do with avoiding competition from the children by eating them, as
described in the book "The Master Switch" by Tim Wu).

Thanks, Henry


On 1/31/11 10:12 AM, "Matthew Kaufman" <matthew.kaufman at skype.net> wrote:

> On 1/29/2011 6:35 AM, Jonathan Rosenberg wrote:
>> 
>> That said, even if one asks the question of whether it is a good idea
>> for us to pick something, I think the answer is no. The enormous
>> benefit of the web model is its ability for innovation and velocity.
>> Standardization is not needed for communications within the domain of
>> the provider; new features can be developed and deployed as quickly as
>> they can be conceived.
> 
> Agreed. Consider the case of Gmail (or any other web-based email)
> 
> Did every web browser on the planet need to be upgraded to speak IMAP or
> SMTP in order for Gmail to be implemented? No.
> 
> Does the JavaScript that Gmail sends down to your browser in order to
> implement its UI need to be standardized among web email platforms? No.
> 
> Does Google need to use the same JavaScript libraries and PHP back-end
> that SquirrelMail uses in order to implement a web email application? No.
> 
> Can Google change that JavaScript tomorrow without breaking
> interoperability? Yes, and they probably will.
> 
> But could Gmail be as successful without the worldwide SMTP
> infrastructure it ties in to? Probably not.
> 
> I see the same situation here. A web browser with real-time
> communication capabilities will work in conjunction with a web site that
> serves up the HTML and JavaScript that makes up the calling application.
> For some applications, this will be sufficient. For others, one will
> want to implement SIP or XMPP/Jingle or something else in order to
> gateway these calls to other networks. The SIP implementation can live
> in the JavaScript, up in the web server, in a separate gateway, or any
> combination thereof.
> 
> Matthew Kaufman
> _______________________________________________
> dispatch mailing list
> dispatch at ietf.org
> https://www.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/dispatch