My thoughts about the problems of the IETF
Brian E Carpenter
brian at hursley.ibm.com
Fri May 2 17:47:36 CEST 2003
Eric Rosen wrote:
>
> > two ways that outside reviewers might help reduce workload:
>
> > 1. require all documents to have N favorable outside reviews, each
> > from an IESG-appointed reviewer pool, before going to IESG review
>
> > 2. provide that any document which has more than Z unfavorable
> > reviews from the reviewer pool need not be considered by IESG
>
> This has the obvious problem that the IESG could stack the pool of reviewers
> so as to achieve any goal they want, and there would be even less
> accountability than there is today.
Obviously, we would adopt an open process for choosing the pool
of reviewers. I would also be in favour of the reviews being posted
on ietf.org.
Brian
More information about the Problem-statement
mailing list