Perceived consensus on Problem Doc

[Avri Doria]

The Problem document does deal with many of the issues that are 
inherent in the IETF Standards process.  So while it does not 
explicitly get into the comparison with other SDO release processes or 
use the release language of these other SDOs, it does open the door to 
discussions about the IETF engineering and document process.  In fact a 
BOF was held and a mailing list established for discussing the IETF 
Standard process as a result of some of the problem WG discussions.

As for the IPR issue, there is a WG that focuses exclusively on IPR 
issues.  I think that would be the right venue for discussions about 
validating those who submit IPR claims.

a.


On onsdag, dec 3, 2003, at 23:37 Asia/Seoul, todd glassey wrote:

> Avri,
> You still have not dealt with the issues of the release
> process or in validating that anyone submitting IP to
> the IETF has the legal ability to do so...
>
> Todd
>