Montenegrin
Doug Ewell
doug at ewellic.org
Thu Jun 17 07:11:48 CEST 2010
Leif Halvard Silli <xn dash dash mlform dash iua at xn dash dash mlform
dash iua dot no> wrote:
> I took up whether 'sh' is a macrolangauge because iso639-3@ said they
> wanted input on Montenengrin and because 'sh' was discussed in that
> context.
I know they wanted input on Montenegrin. I'm not sure they wanted the
issue of Serbo-Croatian as a macrolanguage to be reopened.
> That said: The general problem perhaps more is that many tend to think
> that 'macrolanguage' is a term firmly rooted in linguistic theory. For
> example, the Serbo-Croatian article on Serbo-Croatian language says
> that "modern linguists" look at Serbo-Croatian as a "living
> macrolanguage". [1] And as basis for this claim, the article points to
> SIL. [2]
>
> Many Wikipedia articles on languages of course dutifully list
> languages as "macrolanguage", but I find that if the term is _only_ a
> term that is locked into ISO 639-3, [3] then, what use is it in
> listing it as a macrolanguage outside the Language Subtag Registry and
> similar places? What would be useful was an article that listed all
> macrolanguages and explained why each of them was considered as such
> by ISO 639-3.
I don't know what other writers and other sources use as their working
definition of "macrolanguage." I assume they can define the term
however they please, for their purposes. For purposes of the Language
Subtag Registry, it means exactly the ISO 639-3 definition, which is
available at http://www.sil.org/iso639-3/scope.asp#M .
Because parties other than ISO 639-3/RA may define this term
differently, it is possible that some users of the Registry may get the
wrong impression when they see "Scope: macrolanguage", especially if
they are looking for a particular linguistic relationship. However,
there is nothing that this group can or should try to do about that.
--
Doug Ewell | Thornton, Colorado, USA | http://www.ewellic.org
RFC 5645, 4645, UTN #14 | ietf-languages @ is dot gd slash 2kf0s
More information about the Ietf-languages
mailing list