Katakana Middle Dot again (Was: tables-06b.txt: A.5, A.6, A.9)

Gervase Markham gerv at mozilla.org
Mon Jul 27 20:54:53 CEST 2009


On 25/07/09 15:11, Michel SUIGNARD wrote:
> At this point, I would prefer (somehow reluctantly) to have the Kana
> middle dot PVALID, instead of a complex contextual rule that some
> implementers are definitively going to get wrong.

And I would prefer it to be DISALLOWED rather than PVALID, if we are 
going to eliminate the rules.

It's not just about appearance.

"Yes Dad, as long as you are on double-you double-you double-you dot 
paypal dot com, you are in the right place."

"Hmm. I've got three double-yous, a dot, and then paypal then another 
dot, and then com. That seems to be what he was saying. I must be OK."

Dot and slash-like characters are uniquely problematic, and dot even 
more than slash, because top-level domains have dots but no slashes.

Gerv


More information about the Idna-update mailing list