Patrik Fältström patrik at
Tue Mar 18 17:27:16 CET 2008

On 18 mar 2008, at 16.58, Paul Hoffman wrote:

>> Making them DISALLOWED now makes it harder to allow them later. No?
> Yes, but so does making a CONTEXT* mapping that we want to change  
> later. Any change to a character other than taking it out of  
> UNASSIGNED, exactly once, is an equivalent instability.

Once upon a time, we had a MAYBE category, but that is since long time  
gone. This is one of the examples where I wanted such a category.

Now we have to do The Right Thing.


1. Join_Control is CONTEXTJ
2. (Rest of) Cf is DISALLOWED
3. The rest is like in -05, i.e. my last proposed change is rejected

Let me do a test on that.


More information about the Idna-update mailing list