tables document [Re: IDNA comments]

Patrik Fältström patrik at
Mon Jul 14 22:01:18 CEST 2008

On 14 jul 2008, at 21.57, Kenneth Whistler wrote:

> I don't see that Mark's concern has actually been addressed
> yet on this point (Section 5. IANA Considerations).

Correct. If you see the list of issues I sent, you see this as (as I  
see it) the only thing I can see might be controversial. But on the  
other hand, exactly what change control the wg want for the tables,  
rules etc is not tied to THIS document, but a general issue for the wg.

I will send my personal(!!!) view on this in a separate message as I  
want to separate my personal view from my role as editor.

> P.S. In general, I'm quite pleased with the progress this
> document has made. I find it much simpler and clearer
> now.


But please see the issue list I sent as well.


More information about the Idna-update mailing list