idnabis-tables-04 problem #2: OldHangulJamo

Patrik Fältström patrik at frobbit.se
Mon Dec 22 15:30:08 CET 2008


On 6 dec 2008, at 01.23, Kenneth Whistler wrote:

> =====================================================
>
> 2.9 OldHangulJamo (I)
>
> I: HangulSyllableType(cp) is in {L, V, T}
>
> This category consists of certain Hangul Jamo (Leading Jamo, Vowel
> Jamo and Trailing Jamo) that can create confusability at time of
> display.
>
> =====================================================

New:

> =====================================================
>
> 2.9 Jamo (I)
>
> I: Hangul_Syllable_Type(cp) is in {L, V, T}
>
> This category consists of all conjoining Hangul Jamo
> (Leading Jamo, Vowel Jamo, and Trailing Jamo).
>
> ======================================================
>
> If the group then feels that a justification needs to
> be included somehow to explain why 2.9 is defined as
> a category at all in idnabis-tables-04, then I suggest:
>
> "Elimination of conjoining Hangul Jamos from the set
> of PVALID characters results in restricting the set
> of Korean PVALID characters just to preformed, modern
> Hangul syllable characters. Old Hangul syllables,
> which must be spelled with sequences of conjoining Hangul
> Jamos, are not PVALID for IDNs."

Added!

    Patrik



More information about the Idna-update mailing list