Document: draft-mrose-rfc3288bis-01
Review: Lakshminath Dondeti
Date: 11 maj 2005 


Draft is ready to be published as Proposed Standard.

++++++++++++

Q: In Section 9, why is "must" in small case.  Does it mean a "MUST"?

Note: I have had a chance to take a peek at the tracker and have the
following thoughts on Russ H.'s note on crypto algorithms:

In the IPsec/IKEv2 world, the current crypto algorithms
recommendations are as follows: 3DES-CBC is a MUST- (currently a MUST,
but may no longer be the case in the future) and AES-CBC is a SHOULD+
(might soon take the place of MUST); similarly HMAC-MD5 is a MAY and
HMAC-SHA-1 is a MUST.  Within SASL, it appears that DIGEST-MD5
(HMAC-MD5) seems to be the choice even in the current I-Ds.  The
security ADs might have further insight into how to make these
recommendations consistent across the IETF to the extent practical
(backward compatibility etc.)