Document: Review of draft-ietf-enum-epp-e164-07.txt
From: Suzanne Woolf
Date: 17 november 2004 



intended status:  Proposed Standard

This draft is ready for publication as a Proposed Standard RFC. It
describes a small but important extension to EPP to support ENUM,
allowing for the mapping of ENUM E.164 numbers to an EPP registry and
then to NAPTR records for use in the DNS.

It's clear and straightforward, and seems adequately detailed to allow
implementors to support E.164 in EPP without adding any unintended
complexity or contradiction. I'm not entirely competent to debug the
XML, but there are no obvious errors, and comparison with the existing
NAPTR spec doesn't show any inconsistency-- it tracks the ENUM
specification quite closely.

The IANA Considerations is brief but seems adequate-- two new
assignments in an existing registry. And the Security Considerations
section is quite clear that this extension introduces no new security
issues but also assumes reliance on mechanisms already in EPP.