Document: draft-hoffman-gopher-uri-03.txt
Reviewer: Elwyn Davies
AD: Ted Hardie
Review Date: 17 March 2005
Intended status: Proposed Standard
Trigger: IETF last call, 3 March 2005

Review: This document splits the registration of the (near obsolete) gopher 
(incorporating gopher+) URI scheme out of RFC1738 so that RFC1738 can be made 
obsolete whilst maintaining the gopher scheme on standards track.  The 
substantive parts of main body of the document (section 2) appear to be a 
faithful copy of Section 3.4 of RFC1738.

It is therefore (over) ready for PS give or take two queries and an editorial 
nit:
- In the abstract we have 'This document specifies the gopher1 Uniform...' 
                                                            === 
  I presume this is a mistake rather than intentional and should be 'gopher'.
- Although this is not a new scheme, I guess this document ought to have a short 
IANA considerations section instructing IANA to update the reference for the 
gopher URI scheme from RFC1738 to whatever RFC this becomes.
- Section 3: For consistency in the second sentence: 
  s/gopher protocol/Gopher protocol/