Document: draft-haverinen-pppext-eap-sim-15.txt
From: John Loughney
Date: 2 december 2004 


First off, conflict of interest statement: I work with the editor, and
my company has deployed solutions based upon this draft.

That out of the way, I think this is ready for publication.  This
solution is being deployed in some networks, and it is needed by 3GPP.

The document is well written and basically I couldn't find any real
nits to complain about, and as I understand Bernard Aboba has done an
extensive review with respect to EAP usage, so I will assume his
review covered EAP/Authentication/Authorization mechanisms.

The draft is quite lengthy (91 pages) but much of the document also
covers background GSM material - I note the -00 draft was just 14
pages.