Guernsey Jersey and Isle of Man ISO 3166-1 Codes
Doug Ewell
dewell at adelphia.net
Thu Mar 23 23:59:15 CET 2006
Debbie Garside <debbie at ictmarketing dot co dot uk> wrote:
> However, I would point out that the problem is not in getting
> notifications.
>
> In order to get GG JE and IM registered for use (as well as their
> alpha3 equivalents) as was called for on this list a few months ago,
> 4 Governments were involved in the creation and sanctioning of an
> eleven page document supporting the application! Plus two Standards
> bodies involved in delivering the goods! Just a small feat as Frank
> says ;-)
I understand now. I was talking about the problem of finding out about
new ISO or UN code elements, so we could register subtags based on them.
You were talking about a different type of problem: persuading the
standards organizations to approve new code elements on the basis of
demand from the language tagging community.
I suspect, however, that your recent success in getting GG and IE and JE
assigned will actually be a rare occurrence. These entities were
already assigned numeric code elements in UN M.49, and were very much an
exception to the general rule about ISO 3166/MA taking its list of
"countries" from UNSD; next week's assignments will simply remove that
exception.
For ISO 3166/MA to assign a code element to an entity *not* already
covered by UN M.49 would be quite another matter. It would involve them
in the political debate over "what is a country?" which they have
generally handed off to the UN. Getting such an assignment on the basis
that someone needs it in a language tag seems even more remote, similar
to their FAQ about not assigning a country code simply because someone
wants it as a ccTLD.
--
Doug Ewell
Fullerton, California, USA
http://users.adelphia.net/~dewell/
More information about the Ietf-languages
mailing list