Protocol-12

John C Klensin klensin at jck.com
Fri May 8 23:58:05 CEST 2009


Ok.

Protocol-12 is now in the posting queue and should show up soon.
This is mostly an editorial-smoothing draft, but I believe it
captures all comments to date that either were reported on as
having consensus or were discussed for a while and no dissent
reported to proposed conclusions, with two major and
interconnected exceptions, both noted in the text:

(1) I have not addressed the mapping issues at all.  The text
about it is more or less (probably identically) the same as what
came into San Francisco.  I do not propose to make further
changes here until we have rough consensus on at least the
general flavor of a posted mapping document.

(2) There have been several requests to make the language and
section numbering of Sections 4 (registration) and 5 (lookup)
exactly parallel.  As noted in the text, I'm not going to try to
do that until we have settled enough on the mapping topics that
I don't have to do it again after mapping materials and
references are added or removed.

Awaiting your comments...

Rationale will follow as soon as it is ready.

    john



More information about the Idna-update mailing list